Thread 02 · Technology and Dehumanization · September 25, 2026 · 2 min read

The right to talk to a human

In Quebec, Law 25 requires businesses to say when a machine alone has made a decision, and to let the person explain themselves to someone.

Aspect Tel-set telephone call centre
Photo: Aspect Tel-set telephone call centre · Petiatil · CC BY-SA 3.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

The Story Granary

It was on the 67 bus.

Mamadou read on his phone: "Your credit application has been declined." No name, no reason, just a "Close" button.

That evening, his neighbour reminded him that in Quebec, you can ask why. He wrote in. A few days later, an adviser called him.

His address had been entered incorrectly in the file. A typo, not a verdict on him.

(This scene is invented. What follows is not.)

This right to ask why is real. It is written in the law.

In 2021, Quebec adopted Law 25. It modernized the rules on personal information. It came into force in stages, until 2024.

Among its new features was one section: 12.1.

Picture an automatic door closing in front of you.

Section 12.1 is the doorbell right beside it. The one that brings someone out.

When a business makes a decision by machine alone, it must tell the person. No later than when it tells them of the decision.

On request, it must also explain three things: the information used, the reasons, and the main factors behind the decision. The person can have that information corrected.

And above all, they must be able to present their point of view to a member of staff who can review the decision.

A human. Not a "Close" button.

The law also requires people to be told before technologies are used that allow them to be identified, located or profiled. These functions must not be activated by default.

A business that breaks these rules risks penalties that can reach $10 million.

Incorrect data or a hidden bias can weigh more heavily on some people than on others.

The text of section 12.1 puts it this way:

“The person concerned must be given the opportunity to submit observations”
Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector, section 12.1, added in 2021

We become persons in the gaze and the answers of others: that is what Ubuntu reminds us. Being able to ask a human being "why?" puts a relationship back where there was only a calculation.

A person who gets an answer is a person who is recognized.

Someone around you may have received a "no" with no explanation. They may not yet know they have the right to ask why.

And you?

The last time an app told you no, would you have known whom to ask why, and who around you would need to know?

Pass this story on

Figures

$10Mmaximum administrative penalty, or 2% of worldwide turnover
3things you can demand to know after an automated decision

Sources

  1. LégisQuébec, Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (CQLR, c. P-39.1), section 12.1 (French version). www.legisquebec.gouv.qc.ca
  2. Commission d'accès à l'information du Québec, main changes introduced by Law 25 (in French). www.cai.gouv.qc.ca

Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.

Tags

Read also

Thread 02

The machine does not refuse alone

Ottawa requires its departments to assess the risks of their algorithms before using them, and to keep a human in the loop when the answer is no.

Read
Thread 02

Three billion faces without permission

A company copied billions of faces online to sell a tool to police. Four Canadian commissioners said no together.

Read
Thread 02

A Seat at the Table

On October 2, 2026, Ottawa created an expert council on artificial intelligence. Earlier in the year, organizations and experts had set their own table so that those most affected would be heard.

Read

The daily story

Get every story by email.

One true story a day, free and ad-free.

Or follow the RSS feed.