Thread 02 · Technology and Dehumanization · September 25, 2026
Three billion faces without permission
A company copied billions of faces online to sell them to police; four Canadian commissioners said no together.
1 · The scene
At Sunday supper in Trois-Rivières, Josée scrolls through her public photos: her son's graduation, the cottage, ten years of smiles shared with the cousins.
Her nephew, a computer science student, gently asks her: "Do you know who else can collect those?" She laughs, then stops. She had posted for her own people, not for strangers sorting faces.
Original vignette
2 · The documented case
The joint investigation into Clearview AI
In February 2021, four privacy authorities published the findings of a joint investigation: the federal Office of the Privacy Commissioner, Quebec's Commission d'accès à l'information and their counterparts in British Columbia and Alberta. Their subject: the American company Clearview AI, which had scraped more than three billion images of faces from the Internet, including those of a great many people in Canada, children included, to sell a facial recognition tool.
The commissioners concluded that this amounted to mass identification and surveillance, carried out without consent. In Canada, 48 accounts had been opened for police forces and other organizations. The company had left the Canadian market in July 2020, during the investigation, but it refused the commissioners' recommendations.
In December 2021, the Commission d'accès à l'information ordered Clearview to stop collecting images of Quebecers without their consent and to destroy, within 90 days, those already collected.
What stands out is the common voice. From one end of the country to the other, institutions recalled that a face is not a raw material. It belongs to a person, and to the community that recognizes and protects them.
3 · The voice
“What Clearview does is mass surveillance and it is illegal.”
4 · The question
When you share online the face of someone you love, who should have a say in what becomes of it?
Sources
- Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada and counterparts, Joint investigation of Clearview AI, February 2021. www.priv.gc.ca
- Statement by Commissioner Daniel Therrien, February 3, 2021. www.priv.gc.ca
- Commission d'accès à l'information du Québec, news release, December 14, 2021 (in French). www.newswire.ca
Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.
Tags
Read also
A tool too good to be honest
The RCMP used facial recognition software built on photos that the commissioners found had been collected illegally; even the police must know where their tools come from.
ReadA resemblance is not proof
In Detroit, a Black father was wrongly arrested in front of his daughters because of software; his courage changed the police's rules.
ReadThe machine does not refuse alone
Ottawa requires its departments to assess the risks of their algorithms before using them, and to keep a human in the loop when the answer is no.
Read