The Daily Ubuntu · dailyubuntu.com · Printable sheet
Thread 02 · Technology and Dehumanization · September 25, 2026 · 2 min read
The machine does not refuse alone
Ottawa requires its departments to assess the risks of their algorithms before using them, and to keep a human in the loop when the answer is no.

The Story Granary
It was in a café in Parc-Extension.
Priya refreshed her email for the tenth time. Her mother, still in India, was waiting for an answer. She wanted to come and hold her first grandchild.
A friend had told her: "Now it's a computer that decides." Priya stared at her screen. Could a computer understand what it means for a grandmother to cross the planet for a baby?
(This scene is invented. What follows is not.)
In Canada, there are rules meant to keep the machine from deciding alone.
In 2019, the government started governing its own algorithms through a Treasury Board directive on automated decision-making.
It covered decisions that affect people's rights or interests. Reviewing a benefits application, for example. Or entry into the country.
It applied to systems designed or purchased after April 1, 2020. Its goal: transparent, accountable and fair decisions.
Think of a pilot's checklist before takeoff.
Before launching a system, a department must complete an Algorithmic Impact Assessment. It has 65 questions on risks, and 41 on ways to reduce them.
The result places the system on one of four impact levels. It must be published on the Open Government Portal.
In 2023, the directive was revised. It strengthened bias testing and the obligation to explain decisions.
A concrete example comes from immigration.
Since 2018, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada has used advanced analytics to sort temporary resident visa applications. The department started with those from China and India.
The system identifies simple files. Their eligibility can be assessed 87% faster.
But the final decision still belongs to officers.
The department also says it reviews its tools to detect bias. In 2022, in a note to a parliamentary committee, it put it in black and white:
“The system never refuses applications, nor does it recommend refusals.”
A decision that touches a life is a relationship between people. Ubuntu says it in its own way: we become someone only through others. Behind every file, there is a family waiting for a human answer.
A machine can help.
But it is a human being who must carry the weight of a refusal, and answer for it.
Today, someone may be waiting for an answer from you. Not from a system.
And you?
When a decision changes the course of a life, whom would you want to hear the answer from, and why?
My answers:
Figures
Sources
- Government of Canada, Algorithmic Impact Assessment. www.canada.ca
- Government of Canada, Guide on the Scope of the Directive on Automated Decision-Making. www.canada.ca
- Government of Canada, Amendments to the Directive on Automated Decision-Making. www.canada.ca
- IRCC, advanced analytics and temporary resident visa applications, note to the CIMM committee, May 12, 2022. www.canada.ca
- OECD.AI, profile of Canada's Directive on Automated Decision-Making. oecd.ai
Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.
Tags
Read also
A Seat at the Table
On October 2, 2026, Ottawa created an expert council on artificial intelligence. Earlier in the year, organizations and experts had set their own table so that those most affected would be heard.
Read"You're not from here": the weight of four words
Even people born in Canada are often reminded that they supposedly come "from somewhere else." Statistics Canada's figures show how heavy those words can be.
ReadA tool too good to be honest
The RCMP used facial recognition software built on photos that the commissioners found had been collected illegally. Even the police must know where their tools come from.
Read