The Daily Ubuntu · dailyubuntu.com · Printable sheet
Thread 03 · Racialized but Human · September 29, 2026 · 2 min read
Staying with discomfort: the suspicion that sticks to your skin
In Montreal, as elsewhere in Canada, young Black people are more often arrested and suspected. Numbers that disturb us, and that ask us to listen.
The Story Granary
It was one evening, at a kitchen table.
A man was reading an article full of numbers about justice. The numbers disturbed him.
He felt a resistance rising, the urge to answer back, to explain. He put the paper down.
This discomfort, he told himself, was not a moral failing. It was a signal: learn, listen, adjust.
The next day, a co-worker told him about an identity check. This time, instead of defending himself, he drew closer. Instead of explaining, he listened.
(This scene is invented. What follows is not.)
Here are some of those numbers.
In the 2021 Census, Black people made up 4.3% of the Canadian population.
Yet in 2021-2022, they represented 9.2% of people held in federal penitentiaries. Mostly young men, the Office of the Correctional Investigator stresses.
In Montreal, two researchers, Bernard and McAll, had studied the files of young people who went through the justice system in 2001.
On the island, 26 young Black people per thousand had been arrested and prosecuted. Compared with 13 young white people per thousand.
Twice as many.
In some files on young Black people, the officer mentioned a suspicion of street gang membership. Not a single file on a young white person contained such a suspicion.
That suspicion carries weight.
In 2008, Fredy Villanueva died. After his death, a criminologist commissioned by the Montreal police, Mathieu Charest, made a finding.
Of the young Black men in Montréal-Nord and Saint-Michel, 30 to 40% had already been subjected to an identity check. Among their white peers, it was 5 to 6%.
The police then kept a database of some 10,000 names possibly linked to gangs. Yet they estimated the real number of members at around 500.
These gaps say nothing about a different nature. They reveal more suspicious eyes.
And eyes can be educated.
Every police officer, judge, teacher or neighbour who chooses to listen rather than presume undoes a little of this prejudice.
In 1995, in South Africa, a judge of the Constitutional Court, Pius Langa, said that each person is:
“entitled to unconditional respect, dignity, value and acceptance from the members of the community”
Ubuntu reminds us that justice is not only an institution. It is a way of seeing the other as a member of one's own family.
Staying with discomfort is therefore not a weakness. It is a responsibility: to listen to those who carry this suspicion.
The question
When numbers shake your image of justice, what pushes you to defend yourself? And what would happen if you chose to listen instead?
My answers:
Figures
Sources
- Office of the Correctional Investigator, backgrounder on the 2021-2022 annual report. oci-bec.gc.ca
- Statistics Canada, "By the numbers: Black History Month 2023" (2021 Census). www.statcan.gc.ca:443
- L. Bernard and C. McAll, "La mauvaise conseillère : jeunes Noirs et système de justice," Revue du CREMIS, winter 2010 (in French). stagingapi.cremis.ca
- CBC News, "How the myth of the Montreal street gang led to more street checks on Black youths," 2020. amp.cbc.ca
- McMaster University, "Black people are overrepresented in Ontario's jails" (Owusu-Bempah et al., Race and Justice, 2021). fammed.mcmaster.ca
- South African Human Rights Commission, text citing Justice Langa on Ubuntu. www.sahrc.org.za
Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.
Tags
Read also
Driving without being a suspect
A young Black Montrealer, often pulled over without ever being ticketed, took his case all the way to the Supreme Court. Two Quebec courts recognized racial profiling.
ReadFredy Villanueva, 18, and what the coroner asked of us
In 2008, Fredy Villanueva, 18, was killed by a police officer in Montréal-Nord. Five years later, a coroner described a chain of errors and called for change.
ReadWhat we braid, what we tear away
In Montréal-Nord, SPVM employees reported behaviour now under allegations of racism at Station 39. Colleagues who refused to stay silent.
Read