Thread 03 · Racialized but Human · September 15, 2026 · 2 min read

Fredy Villanueva, 18, and what the coroner asked of us

In 2008, Fredy Villanueva, 18, was killed by a police officer in Montréal-Nord. Five years later, a coroner described a chain of errors and called for change.

Parc Aimé-Léonard (Montréal-Nord)
Photo: Parc Aimé-Léonard (Montréal-Nord) · Parcours riverain - Ville de Montréal · CC BY 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

The Story Granary

It was August 9, 2008, in Montréal-Nord, near the Henri-Bourassa arena.

A group of young people were playing dice.

Montreal police officers approached them.

Fredy Villanueva, 18, was shot and killed. Two other young people were wounded.

Fredy never made it home.

The next day, a riot broke out in the neighbourhood.

In December 2008, the prosecution authorities announced that no charges would be laid against the officer.

Then came the coroner's public inquiry. It was long interrupted. It only concluded in December 2013, five years later.

Coroner André Perreault found that the evidence did not establish that Fredy was trying to disarm an officer.

He noted that several of the people involved had made mistakes, some for lack of training. And the investigation into his death, he added, had been conducted in a way that made the truth harder to establish.

Among his recommendations:

Review the choice of service weapons.

Train officers better in the use of force and in working with diverse communities. Train them better, too, in distinguishing between criminal, racial and social profiling.

Explain to high school students their rights and obligations when they are stopped.

No report gives a son back to his mother.

But a coroner's recommendations are a collective promise: that a teenager's death should serve to protect those who come after.

For years, families, Montréal-Nord organizations and rights advocates carried this memory. What remains is to check, recommendation by recommendation, what has really changed.

In his report, the coroner wrote:

“Fredy Villanueva did not deserve to die.”
André Perreault, coroner, public inquiry report, as translated by CBC News, 2013

No one grows up alone, Ubuntu reminds us. A neighbourhood's teenagers are not the children of one family alone. They are everyone's children.

Seeing them that way is the first protection we owe them.

The question

What changes in a neighbourhood when we see its teenagers first as everyone's children, rather than as a threat to be managed?

Pass this story on

Figures

18Fredy Villanueva's age in 2008
2other young people wounded during the intervention

Sources

  1. CBC News, coroner's report, 2013 www.cbc.ca
  2. CTV Montreal, coroner's report, 2013 montreal.ctvnews.ca
  3. CTV Montreal, coroner's inquiry resumes, 2012 montreal.ctvnews.ca
  4. CBC News, no charges, 2008 www.cbc.ca

Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.

Tags

Read also

Thread 03

Staying with discomfort: the suspicion that sticks to your skin

In Montreal, as elsewhere in Canada, young Black people are more often arrested and suspected. Numbers that disturb us, and that ask us to listen.

Read
Thread 03

Driving without being a suspect

A young Black Montrealer, often pulled over without ever being ticketed, took his case all the way to the Supreme Court. Two Quebec courts recognized racial profiling.

Read
Thread 03

What we braid, what we tear away

In Montréal-Nord, SPVM employees reported behaviour now under allegations of racism at Station 39. Colleagues who refused to stay silent.

Read

The daily story

Get every story by email.

One true story a day, free and ad-free.

Or follow the RSS feed.