Thread 03 · Racialized but Human · September 25, 2026 · 2 min read

Time given back

In the United States, a kidney health calculation adjusted for race delayed transplants for Black patients. It was withdrawn, and then their lost time was given back.

Hemodialysismachine
Photo: Hemodialysismachine · CC BY-SA 3.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

The Story Granary

It was in a waiting room in Montreal.

A woman was scrolling through her lab results on her phone. One line puzzled her: a number about her kidneys, obtained using a formula she didn't know.

At her appointment, she dared to ask: "That number, how is it calculated for someone like me?"

The doctor put down his pen and took the time to explain. She left reassured, and proud of having asked.

(This scene is invented. What follows is not.)

Her question was the right one.

To find out whether the kidneys are working well, doctors use a formula. It estimates how well the kidneys are doing their job.

For years, in the United States, this formula took race into account. For Black people, it made their kidneys look healthier than they were.

It is like a line-up.

You are told to wait off to the side, because you look healthy. Meanwhile, your turn isn't counting.

That is what was happening. In Black people, the disease was recognized later. So they started accumulating time on the transplant waiting list later.

On September 23, 2021, two American kidney associations recommended a new formula, without race.

Then the U.S. transplant network went further.

Starting January 5, 2023, transplant programs had to identify disadvantaged Black patients. And give them back the waiting time they had lost.

A year later, 14,701 files had been corrected.

A median of 1.7 years of waiting time was restored.

Among these people, 2,709 received a kidney from a deceased donor, and 158 from a living donor.

Here, repair was very concrete: acknowledging the error, then giving everyone back their rightful place in line.

In 2023, the president of the board of the U.S. transplant network named the error:

“a race-based calculation that unfairly delayed care for many Black patients”
Jerry McCauley, president of the board of the U.S. Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN), 2023

We exist through one another, Ubuntu teaches. A waiting list is therefore a promise made to everyone at once. When one person loses their place, the shared promise cracks.

Changing a rule is not always enough. We also have to give one another back the time it took.

Someone may still be waiting off to the side of the line, without knowing why.

And you?

When a rule has done harm, is it enough to change it, or must we also give back what it took? Around you, which rule deserves to be questioned?

Pass this story on

Figures

14,701waiting-list files corrected in one year
1.7 yearsof waiting time restored, median

Sources

  1. National Kidney Foundation, "NKF and ASN Release New Way to Diagnose Kidney Diseases," September 23, 2021. www.kidney.org
  2. UNOS, "Waiting time adjustment approved for kidney transplant candidates affected by race-based calculation," 2023. unos.org
  3. HRSA / OPTN, "Over 14,700 Waiting Time Modifications Completed for Black Kidney Patients One Year After Policy Implementation," 2024. www.hrsa.gov

Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.

Tags

Read also

Thread 03

The mirror: one species, very real categories

Science confirms it: human races do not exist in biology. Racism, however, invented categories that still wound.

Read
Thread 03

The invisible gears: pain that isn't believed

False beliefs about Black people's bodies still circulate in medicine. In 2016, a study showed that they change the way their pain is measured.

Read
Thread 03

May my curiosity be a form of care: SLĀV and cultural appropriation

In 2018, the show SLĀV divided Montreal. It offered an opportunity to ask how to borrow from a culture without erasing its history.

Read

The daily story

Get every story by email.

One true story a day, free and ad-free.

Or follow the RSS feed.