Thread 03 · Racialized but Human · September 29, 2026 · 2 min read

The invisible gears: pain that isn't believed

False beliefs about Black people's bodies still circulate in medicine. In 2016, a study showed that they change the way their pain is measured.

2020 engadiner holzraederuhr uhrwerk
Photo: 2020 engadiner holzraederuhr uhrwerk · Rhetos · CC0 · via Wikimedia Commons

The Story Granary

It was after a shift.

A young medical resident was thinking back to something a friend had said: "There's a difference between what we know and what we believe."

She knew systemic racism exists. But believing that it seeps into her gestures, her institutions, her silences, that was something else.

She told herself: a system is not a wall. It is a collective habit, like software running in the background. And any habit can be changed.

(This scene is invented. What follows is not.)

One study brought that invisible software to light.

It was 2016. A University of Virginia team asked 222 white medical students and residents about false beliefs.

That Black people's skin is thicker. That their nerve endings are less sensitive. That their blood clots faster.

Half endorsed at least one of these ideas.

Half.

And these beliefs did not stay abstract. Faced with mock cases, those who endorsed them rated a Black patient's pain as less intense than a white patient's. Their treatment recommendations were also less accurate.

Those who rejected these beliefs showed no such bias.

Two people say "It hurts" in the very same words. If you believe, without knowing it, that one of them feels less, you no longer hear the same sentence.

These ideas have a long history. Medicine has often treated "race" as a biological fact. Right down to its formulas.

In 2023, the American Thoracic Society recommended abandoning race-adjusted spirometry equations.

These equations were used to read a breathing test. For it to be judged abnormal, they required a Black patient's results to be lower. Sometimes by 15%, compared with a white patient of the same sex, height and age.

They risked delaying diagnoses.

But what has been learned can be unlearned. The 2016 study suggests as much: it is on these specific beliefs that we can act.

In 2000, in Durban, closing an international AIDS conference, Nelson Mandela had said:

“we have once again become our brother's and our sister's keeper”
Nelson Mandela, closing address, 13th International AIDS Conference, Durban, July 14, 2000

Ubuntu reminds the caregiver that another person's pain concerns them. That pain is not a figure to be adjusted by skin colour.

Believing someone's pain is already the beginning of caring for them.

Today, someone may tell you they are in pain. What they need first is to be believed.

And you?

In your work or your daily life, which inherited "certainty" deserves to be checked before deciding for someone else?

Pass this story on

Figures

222white medical students and residents surveyed, PNAS, 2016
1 in 2endorsed at least one false belief about Black people's bodies
15%gap sometimes required by the old race-adjusted spirometry equations

Sources

  1. ScienceDaily, University of Virginia news release on the study by Hoffman et al. (PNAS), April 4, 2016. www.sciencedaily.com
  2. University of Virginia, Batten School, working paper by Trawalter, Hoffman, Oliver and Axt. batten.virginia.edu
  3. American Thoracic Society, "ATS Publishes Official Statement on Race, Ethnicity and Pulmonary Function Test Interpretation," 2023. site.thoracic.org
  4. Nelson Mandela, closing address to the 13th International AIDS Conference, July 14, 2000 (Polity). www.polity.org.za

Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.

Tags

Read also

Thread 03

When the device doesn't see the skin

Pulse oximeters can overestimate blood oxygen in people with darker skin. It is a bias hidden in an ordinary object.

Read
Thread 07

Loneliness, a public health issue

Screens promise connection and often deliver isolation. Ubuntu reminds us that we become someone in the presence of others.

Read
Thread 02

Measuring illness in dollars

A U.S. health algorithm judged patients' needs by their past spending. Black patients, who received less care, therefore seemed less sick.

Read

The daily story

Get every story by email.

One true story a day, free and ad-free.

Or follow the RSS feed.