Thread 03 · Racialized but Human · October 4, 2026 · 2 min read

Who Counted as a Person?

The 1929 Persons Case was a real victory. But it did not benefit all women, and some of the women who won it also shut others out.

The Famous Five
Photo: The Famous Five · Mike from Vancouver, Canada · CC BY-SA 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

The Story Granary

It was October 18, 1929, in London.

That day, the Privy Council handed down its decision. It recognized women as "persons."

The question had come from Canada. In 1927, five Alberta women had asked it: Emily Murphy, Nellie McClung, Louise McKinney, Irene Parlby and Henrietta Muir Edwards.

They wanted to know whether the word "persons" in the British North America Act included women. If it did, women could sit in the Senate.

On April 24, 1928, the Supreme Court had said no.

In London, the Privy Council overturned that ruling.

It was a real victory.

But that victory had two sides.

The federal government itself acknowledges it: the decision did not include all women. Indigenous women and women of Asian heritage and descent, among others, were left out.

Manitoba goes further. It says the Famous Five called for equality for only a select type of woman. They largely left out racialized, disabled, 2SLGBTQ+ and Indigenous women.

There is darker still.

According to The Canadian Encyclopedia, Emily Murphy and Nellie McClung supported sterilization in the 1920s.

From 1928 to 1972, under an Alberta law, 2,834 people were sterilized. More than 25 per cent of them were First Nations or Métis.

Manitoba does not suggest erasing the 1929 date. It suggests widening it, by also telling the story of Indigenous women's leadership.

In 1979, an award was given in commemoration of the Persons Case. One of its first recipients was Mary Two-Axe Earley, a Kanien'kehá:ka woman from Kahnawà:ke.

She was then fighting to regain the status the law had taken from her.

Two voices speak to the two sides of this story. That of the 1929 decision. Then that of the Government of Manitoba.

“The exclusion of women from all public offices is a relic of days more barbarous […]”
Lord Sankey, Lord Chancellor of Great Britain, Privy Council decision, 1929
“they also actively worked to perpetuate others.”
Government of Manitoba, on the Famous Five and inequality

In Ubuntu, we are only fully human with others. An "us" that leaves people out remains incomplete.

And that "us" rarely widens all at once. We must keep asking who is still left outside.

To remember 1929 is also to remember those who were still waiting at the door.

The question

When we celebrate a victory for "everyone," can we name those who were still waiting at the door?

Pass this story on

Figures

October 18, 1929the Privy Council recognizes women as "persons"
2,834sterilizations carried out in Alberta under the 1928–1972 law
25%+of those sterilized were First Nations or Métis

Sources

  1. Persons Day (Women and Gender Equality Canada) www.canada.ca
  2. Persons Day (Government of Manitoba) gov.mb.ca
  3. Famous 5 (The Canadian Encyclopedia) thecanadianencyclopedia.ca
  4. Eugenics in Canada (The Canadian Encyclopedia) thecanadianencyclopedia.ca
  5. Statement by the Prime Minister on Persons Day (Prime Minister's Office, 2024, French version) www.pm.gc.ca
  6. Mary Two-Axe Earley (The Canadian Encyclopedia) thecanadianencyclopedia.ca

Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.

Tags

Read also

Thread 03

231 calls, and a candle for each name

On June 3, 2019, the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls issued 231 Calls for Justice. Years later, families are still counting what remains to be done.

Read
Thread 03

Viola Desmond's Little Sister

For decades, Viola Desmond's story stayed in the shadows. Her little sister, Wanda Robson, carried it all the way to the 2010 pardon and the $10 bill.

Read
Thread 07

Friends in the City

In 1950s Winnipeg, Indigenous women opened a door for those arriving alone in the city. The friendship centre movement now counts more than 120 centres.

Read

The daily story

Get every story by email.

One true story a day, free and ad-free.

Or follow the RSS feed.