Thread 02 · Technology and Dehumanization · September 25, 2026 · 2 min read

A resemblance is not proof

In Detroit, a Black father was wrongly arrested in front of his daughters because of facial recognition software. His courage changed the police's rules.

Fingerprint - Central Pocket Loop Whorl
Photo: Fingerprint - Central Pocket Loop Whorl · Saurabh R. Patil · CC BY-SA 3.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

The Story Granary

It was January 2020, in Farmington Hills, in suburban Detroit.

In front of his home, Robert Williams, a Black man, was arrested by police.

Before the eyes of his wife. Before the eyes of his two young daughters.

He was suspected of stealing watches from a downtown store.

The only link: facial recognition software. It had matched a blurry surveillance camera image with an old photo from his driver's licence.

He was not the thief.

Yet he spent 30 hours in detention.

He was not the only one. In Detroit, at least two other people, also Black, had been wrongly arrested because of a false match.

Robert Williams could have stayed silent. He chose to tell his story, again and again, so that other families would not have to live through the same thing.

With the help of the American Civil Liberties Union, he sued the City.

On June 28, 2024, a settlement was reached.

Now Detroit police can no longer arrest someone on the basis of facial recognition alone. Other, independent evidence is required.

Officers must be trained on the technology, and on its heavier impact on people of colour. Arrests linked to the tool since 2017 must be audited.

A resemblance is not proof.

After the settlement, Robert Williams said in an interview:

“They thought it was some kind of magic they were using.”
Robert Williams, in an interview with Michigan Public after the settlement, 2024

Robert Williams is neither an image nor a match score.

He is a husband. A father. A member of a community. That is how he deserves to be seen. Ubuntu reminds us of this: each person exists among their own, never as just one face among others.

No software should decide on its own which of us becomes a suspect.

The question

When a machine points to someone as a suspect, what do we owe that person before believing them guilty?

Pass this story on

Figures

30 hoursspent in detention for a theft he did not commit
2017starting point for the audit of past arrests

Sources

  1. ACLU, Williams v. City of Detroit (case file and settlement). www.aclu.org
  2. Michigan Public, "Wrongful facial recognition arrest in Detroit leads to landmark settlement," June 28, 2024. www.michiganpublic.org
  3. Electronic Frontier Foundation, "Detroit Takes Important Step in Curbing the Harms of Face Recognition Technology," July 2024. www.eff.org

Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.

Tags

Read also

Thread 02

A tool too good to be honest

The RCMP used facial recognition software built on photos that the commissioners found had been collected illegally. Even the police must know where their tools come from.

Read
Thread 02

Robodebt: when the machine accuses

In Australia, an automated calculation wrongly claimed hundreds of thousands of debts from welfare recipients. A royal commission found it cruel and unlawful.

Read
Thread 02

When the "nationality" box becomes a suspicion

In the Netherlands, a tax algorithm treated foreign nationality as a sign of fraud. Tens of thousands of parents were wrongly accused, and a government fell.

Read

The daily story

Get every story by email.

One true story a day, free and ad-free.

Or follow the RSS feed.