Thread 01 · Exile and Migration · September 14, 2026 · 2 min read

Sanctuary city: what a promise can do, and what it can't

In 2017, Montreal declared itself a sanctuary city. In 2018, the City acknowledged the limits of its promise and focused instead on access to its services without fear.

Montreal Twilight Panorama 2006
Photo: Montreal Twilight Panorama 2006 · Diliff · CC BY-SA 3.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

The Story Granary

It was February 20, 2017, in Montreal.

City council voted. Unanimously.

The city became a "sanctuary city."

The City committed to offering access to its programs and services, including housing, to everyone, regardless of status. It asked the federal government for a program to regularize undocumented residents.

It was a big promise.

On December 5, 2018, Mayor Valérie Plante unveiled her first immigration action plan. Yet in it she dropped the term "sanctuary city," which refers to American legal concepts.

The city is home to about 50,000 people without status, according to Global News. And it cannot legally protect them from a deportation ordered by federal authorities.

The plan focused instead on concrete steps.

Removing the proof-of-address requirement at libraries and pools. Working with the police so that vulnerable people would dare to ask for help without fearing for their status.

In June 2019, Montreal launched its Policy on Access to Municipal Services Without Fear.

There are two kinds of doors.

A city does not control the big one, the border. It controls the small ones: the library, the pool, the neighbourhood police station.

The mayor had admitted it plainly:

“Legally, the city can't offer special protection from deportation to migrants.”
Valérie Plante, mayor of Montreal, quoted by Global News, 2018

A municipal promise does not stop a removal order. But it can make sure a mother signs her children up at the library. A family can swim at the neighbourhood pool. A person in danger can dare to call for help.

Every small door that opens brings a neighbour back into the "us." That is how Ubuntu sees a city.

The rest, including regularization, depends on Ottawa. And on the voices of citizens who refuse to let neighbours live in the shadows.

Kept at the right scale, a promise changes a daily life.

Today, someone may still be hesitating to push open a small door.

And you?

A city cannot do everything; but what can you do so that no one around you is afraid to ask for help?

Pass this story on

Figures

50,000people without status in Montreal, estimate reported in 2018

Sources

  1. CTV News, city council vote, 2017 www.ctvnews.ca
  2. Declaration designating Montreal a sanctuary city (International Observatory of Mayors on Living Together), 2017, in French observatoirevivreensemble.org
  3. Global News, immigration action plan, 2018 globalnews.ca
  4. International Observatory of Mayors on Living Together, Montreal profile, 2019 observatoirevivreensemble.org

Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.

Tags

Read also

Thread 01

"You're not from here": the weight of four words

Even people born in Canada are often reminded that they supposedly come "from somewhere else." Statistics Canada's figures show how heavy those words can be.

Read
Thread 01

The "boat people" and a medal for a whole people

In 1979-1980, thousands of Canadians sponsored refugees from Southeast Asia themselves. In 1986, the UN awarded its Nansen Medal to the whole population of Canada.

Read
Thread 01

From Haiti to Montreal: exile that takes root

Since the 1960s, thousands of Haitians have fled dictatorship for Montreal. Through mutual aid, they built a community there that is essential to Quebec.

Read

The daily story

Get every story by email.

One true story a day, free and ad-free.

Or follow the RSS feed.