Thread 01 · Exile and Migration · September 21, 2026 · 2 min read

One permit, one boss, one fear

A UN rapporteur believes that permits tied to a single employer expose foreign workers to exploitation. Ottawa disagrees, but the debate remains open.

Seasonal agricultural workers - geograph.org.uk - 8309137
Photo: Seasonal agricultural workers - geograph.org.uk - 8309137 · Philip Halling · CC BY-SA 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

The Story Granary

It was September 6, 2023, in Canada.

Tomoya Obokata was ending a two-week visit. For the UN, he studied contemporary forms of slavery.

And he issued a warning.

He was pointing at employer-specific work permits, including those of some temporary foreign worker programs. In his view, they make these workers vulnerable to modern slavery.

Why? Because, he said, they cannot report abuse without fearing being sent back to their country.

Keeping quiet so as not to lose your place.

His final report, dated July 22, 2024, maintained that finding before the Human Rights Council.

It described wages partly paid or confiscated. Excessive hours. Harassment. Overcrowded housing. Access to health care sometimes discouraged.

It recommended systematically offering these workers a path to permanent residence.

On September 12, 2024, in Geneva, Canada disputed these findings. A worker, it noted, can legally change employers.

Ottawa cited an open work permit for vulnerable workers, created in 2019. Obligations imposed on employers in 2022, including a ban on reprisals. Nearly $41 million for a migrant worker support program.

Remedies do exist.

But they assume one thing: that an isolated person, who speaks little of the language and whose stay depends on their boss, will dare to use them.

The rapporteur, for his part, had written:

“The Temporary Foreign Worker Program acts as a breeding ground for contemporary forms of slavery.”
Tomoya Obokata, UN Special Rapporteur, report to the Human Rights Council, 2024

The employer-specific permit remains at the heart of the debate.

And so far, what has changed things are workers who testified. Organizations that supported them. Neighbours who stopped looking away.

A fear carried alone becomes silence. Carried together, it can become a voice. That is the strength of Ubuntu: no one finds their courage alone.

The courage to speak grows when someone stands beside you.

That neighbour's role is one all of us can take. Today, someone, perhaps very close by, is waiting to be seen.

And you?

If your neighbour down the road cannot leave his boss without risking his right to be here, are you really neighbours? And what could you do so that he is not left alone with his fear?

Pass this story on

Figures

2019creation of the open work permit for vulnerable workers
$41Mfor the Migrant Worker Support Program

Sources

  1. "UN expert sounds alarm over contemporary forms of slavery in Canada" (UN News, 2023) news.un.org
  2. Report of the Special Rapporteur, visit to Canada, A/HRC/57/46/Add.1 (Human Rights Council, 2024) documents.un.org
  3. Note on the response to the Special Rapporteur (Employment and Social Development Canada, 2024) rechercher.ouvert.canada.ca
  4. "Un rapport compare les travailleurs étrangers du Canada à des esclaves modernes" (Noovo Info, 2024, in French) www.noovo.info

Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.

Tags

Read also

Thread 01

Eight Hundred Volunteers and a Promise

In the summer of 2015, in Guelph, a business leader decided to sponsor 50 Syrian families. More than 800 volunteers of every faith followed him.

Read
Thread 01

What the War Didn't Take

In Syria, bombs destroyed Isam Hadhad's chocolate factory. In Antigonish, Nova Scotia, neighbours helped him start again, one small shed at a time.

Read
Thread 06

Equity is the law

On December 11, 2023, a task force chaired by Adelle Blackett proposed adding Black and 2SLGBTQI+ workers to the Employment Equity Act. That same day, the government announced its intention to do so.

Read

The daily story

Get every story by email.

One true story a day, free and ad-free.

Or follow the RSS feed.