Thread 06 · Economy and Inequality · September 25, 2026 · 2 min read

The answer that never comes

A CMHC experiment showed that in Montreal, rental inquiries from Black, Indigenous or LGBTQ+ tenants received fewer replies.

Montréal Mont-Royal 297
Photo: Montréal Mont-Royal 297 · Alain Rouiller · CC BY-SA 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

The Story Granary

It was June, in a dépanneur.

Between customers, a cashier was scrolling through apartment listings on his phone.

He wrote politely. Always the same message: steady worker, non-smoker, references available.

He sent twelve that week.

His colleague, looking in the same neighbourhood, already had three viewings lined up.

The cashier reread his messages. He saw no mistake. He saw only silence.

(This scene is invented. What follows is not.)

That kind of silence has been measured.

In early 2021, Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, CMHC, ran an experiment in eight large cities, including Montreal and Quebec City.

For real rental listings, fictitious profiles wrote to landlords. About 2,000 emails per region.

The profiles suggested white, Black, Indigenous, Asian or LGBTQ+ people. The messages themselves were drawn at random from a few equivalent templates.

The results came out in October 2024.

In Montreal, nearly all the profiles studied were significantly less likely to receive a reply than a young white man.

For Black profiles, the measured effect reached about −18%. For Indigenous profiles, about −16%.

For LGBTQ+ profiles, it neared −40%.

Elsewhere, results varied by city and group.

The study noticed something else. Most of the replies received were positive and offered a viewing. When the door opened, it often opened wide.

So the issue was the first sort. That moment when a decision is made in a few seconds.

CMHC summed up what it had found this way:

“significant discrimination in landlords' responses, depending on the tenant's profile”
Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, summary of the study, 2024

There is a concrete way to act: answering every inquiry in the order received, with the same criteria for everyone.

For Ubuntu, a neighbourhood is not a row of closed doors. It belongs to everyone who wants to live there.

Every reply given, or withheld, says who is welcomed into the "us."

The question

When a newcomer tries to settle near you, what could your street do so that they feel expected rather than tolerated?

Pass this story on

Figures

−18%measured effect on the chances of a reply, Black profiles, Montreal
−40%measured effect, LGBTQ+ profiles, Montreal (about −39.6%)
8large Canadian cities studied by CMHC

Sources

  1. CMHC, Responses to Rental Inquiries in Canada: Does the Profile Matter?, October 23, 2024. www.cmhc-schl.gc.ca
  2. CMHC, Research Insight, full report, 2024. assets.cmhc-schl.gc.ca

Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.

Tags

Read also

Thread 06

As Much as He Needed Them

In 1988, in Montreal, a 60-year-old priest borrowed $10,000 to buy an old vehicle. At night, he went out to meet the young people sleeping on the street.

Read
Thread 06

The Key First

The At Home/Chez Soi project showed that offering housing first, then support, helps twice as many people stay housed. Meanwhile, homelessness is rising in Quebec.

Read
Thread 06

A score is not a person

Between 300 and 900, a credit score opens or closes doors. It measures a history, never a person's worth.

Read

The daily story

Get every story by email.

One true story a day, free and ad-free.

Or follow the RSS feed.