Thread 06 · Economy and Inequality · September 29, 2026 · 2 min read

Merit never arrives alone

In Quebec, the R score measures a rank, not a road. And in the Toronto area, data show that Black students are suspended far more often.

Sias Library - Students Studying 2017
Photo: Sias Library - Students Studying 2017 · Gary Todd · CC0 · via Wikimedia Commons

The Story Granary

It was in a café, near a CEGEP.

Two friends were comparing their transcripts. Same program, same R score, within a tenth. They burst out laughing: "Twins!"

Then they told each other about their semester.

One had had a tutor two evenings a week and a quiet bedroom. The other had worked twenty hours at the corner store and babysat her little brother on Saturdays.

The number was the same. The road was not.

(This scene is invented. What follows is not.)

In Quebec, universities use the R score mainly to choose who gets into their limited-enrolment programs.

Each CEGEP grade first places the student relative to the average of their group.

Since the fall of 2017, this calculation has been adjusted for the group's strength and for the spread between its students. To do that, it looks at the results those same students had obtained in Secondary 4 and 5.

The goal is fairness. A student surrounded by very strong classmates is not penalized.

The tool is rigorous. But it measures a rank, not the road travelled.

And the adjustment itself relies on high school. Earlier paths continue to count.

It is like a race where only the order of arrival is recorded. No one looks at who started farther back.

These paths are shaped early.

In the United States, people use the phrase "school-to-prison pipeline." It describes how repeated exclusions push some young people away from school and closer to the justice system.

In 2017, in Canada, Professor Carl James of York University led a report on Toronto-area schools.

There, 42% of Black students had been suspended at least once before finishing high school.

Among white students: 18%.

Black students were also more than twice as likely to be streamed into the applied rather than the academic program.

Two thinkers, decades apart, put words to this bond between success and community:

“We took care of the community, and the community took care of us”
Julius Nyerere, "Ujamaa: The Basis of African Socialism," 1962
“It diminishes our capacity to see ourselves as sharing a common fate”
Michael Sandel, on the hubris of the winners, The Tyranny of Merit, 2020

Ubuntu does not deny each person's effort. It simply reminds us that behind every score there are parents, teachers, a neighbourhood.

Merit never arrives alone: it arrives carried.

A school that looks for potential before faults gives all of us the same chance to be carried.

Today, someone near you may be running from farther back than you.

And you?

If you had to name the people who carried your own success, whom would you most easily forget? And what do you owe them?

Pass this story on

Figures

42%of Black students in the Toronto area suspended at least once in high school (compared with 18% of white students)
39%of Black students enrolled in the applied program (compared with 16% of white students)

Sources

  1. Bureau de coopération interuniversitaire, "La cote de rendement au collégial : ce qu'elle est, ce qu'elle fait," July 9, 2018 (in French). www.cegepst.qc.ca
  2. York University, YFile, on the report "Towards Race Equity in Education" (2017), March 20, 2019. yorku.ca
  3. D. Milazi, "African Social Thoughts," quoting Nyerere, University of Dar es Salaam, 1982. journals.udsm.ac.tz
  4. Prospect Magazine, review of The Tyranny of Merit, September 1, 2020. www.prospectmagazine.co.uk

Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.

Tags

Read also

Thread 07

Recess regained

Since 2024, cellphones have been banned in class in Quebec. Since September 2025, they have been banned throughout the school. At one school in Saint-Bruno-de-Montarville, students have filled the gym and the library again.

Read
Thread 03

Being looked at differently at school

In 2011, Quebec's human rights commission documented the racial profiling experienced by young people, even in schools. In 2020, its review showed that much remained to be done.

Read
Thread 03

The path chosen for you at 14

In the Toronto area, Black students were twice as likely to be streamed into the applied program. Ontario eventually abolished Grade 9 streaming.

Read

The daily story

Get every story by email.

One true story a day, free and ad-free.

Or follow the RSS feed.