Thread 05 · War and Reconciliation · September 29, 2026 · 2 min read

The garden with two soils

Racism cannot be reduced to a hateful act. A gardener's fable, told in 2000 by a researcher, helps us see its three levels, and where to start repairing.

The Story Granary

It was evening. A woman opened an old history textbook at random.

The glory of kings. The pride of explorers. The genius of inventors.

And yet an emptiness took hold of her. Not a single story in which she could recognize someone like her friend.

That friend had told her about a gesture. A mother of African descent had found the triangular trade in her daughter's textbook. Without a word about the trafficking of African people.

She had taken a pencil and extended one line. The triangle had become a quadrilateral.

Since then, that image had stayed with the woman: a single gesture can give back a place to those whom history erased.

(This scene is invented. What follows is not.)

We often imagine racism as a hateful act committed by an ill-intentioned person.

In 2000, a public health researcher, Camara Phyllis Jones, proposed another way of seeing it.

To her, racism has three levels. To explain them, she told a fable.

A gardener had two flower boxes.

She sowed the red seeds in rich soil. The pink seeds, in poor, rocky soil.

The pink flowers grew less well. The gardener didn't like their look. She pulled them out before they even went to seed.

And in the end, the pink flowers themselves refused pink pollen. They preferred red.

The three levels were all there.

The unequal soil is the first. Racism that has become the norm, sometimes written into law, often passed on as inherited disadvantage.

The pulled-out flowers are racism between people.

The refused pollen is when we come to believe what is said about us.

For Jones, the fable helps us see where to act. We can comfort each pulled-out flower, and we must. But as long as we don't change the soil, the garden reproduces the same gaps.

So the pencil line in the textbook takes on another meaning. It doesn't touch a single flower.

It touches the soil.

Two voices say it, each in its own way:

“[A person with ubuntu] is diminished when others are humiliated or diminished”
Desmond Tutu, No Future Without Forgiveness, 1999
“And like everything else, if you can learn it, you can unlearn it.”
Jane Elliott, educator, on racism, ASU News, 2017

No one blooms alone in their corner of the box. Ubuntu ties us to one another: the soil we share decides what each of us can become.

When one part of the garden is impoverished, the whole garden blooms less.

Somewhere, a line is still waiting to be drawn. Maybe in a place you know well.

And you?

Around you, what "soil" would need to change so that every flower has the same chance to grow? And what line could you draw yourself?

Pass this story on

Sources

  1. C. P. Jones, "Levels of Racism: A Theoretic Framework and a Gardener's Tale," American Journal of Public Health, 90(8), 2000 (record, University of Maryland). drum.lib.umd.edu
  2. C. P. Jones, same article, full text (copy, University of California). ccfruitandnuts.ucanr.edu
  3. Calvin Theological Seminary, excerpt from D. Tutu, No Future Without Forgiveness, Doubleday, 1999, p. 31. cep.calvinseminary.edu
  4. ASU News, "ASU Project Humanities hosts 'Blue Eyes/Brown Eyes' educator Jane Elliott," November 3, 2017. news.asu.edu

Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.

Tags

Read also

Thread 05

More than our worst moment

In Montgomery, Alabama, a memorial names the victims of lynching. Telling the truth without reducing anyone to their worst act: a path toward shared humanity.

Read
Thread 05

Repairing, for their children and for ours

In 1988, Canada recognized the injustice done to Japanese Canadians during the war and chose to repair, not just to regret.

Read
Thread 05

The battalion no one wanted to see

More than 600 Black volunteers served Canada in 1917-1918, kept away from the front. In 2022, the country finally apologized to them.

Read

The daily story

Get every story by email.

One true story a day, free and ad-free.

Or follow the RSS feed.