Thread 05 · War and Reconciliation · September 2, 2026 · 2 min read

Judging the person, not just the act

Since the Gladue and Ipeelee decisions, a judge must consider an Indigenous person's history before sentencing them. Yet federal prisons have never been so Indigenous.

Supreme Court of Canada, Wellington Street, Ottawa
Photo: Supreme Court of Canada, Wellington Street, Ottawa · Rleir · CC BY-SA 3.0 · via Wikimedia Commons

The Story Granary

It was March 23, 2012, at the Supreme Court of Canada.

That day, the judges handed down R. v. Ipeelee. Six to one. Justice Louis LeBel wrote the reasons.

The decision reaffirmed an older one: the 1999 Gladue decision.

The rule was clear. When sentencing an Indigenous person, even for a serious crime, the judge had to take certain effects into account.

The effects of colonization. Of residential schools. Of the displacement of communities.

Failing to do so was an error of law.

It is a bit like a crooked tree. You cannot judge it without looking at the wind that bent it for years.

The decision was about sentencing, not restorative justice in the strict sense. But the Gladue approach opened a door: to approaches that seek to repair relationships rather than only punish.

For that, the court needs to know the person. That is the role of Gladue reports. They tell the story of their life.

Yet these reports are often missing. For lack of trained writers. For lack of stable funding.

And meanwhile, overrepresentation was worsening.

In 2001, according to the Office of the Correctional Investigator, Indigenous people made up 18% of federal inmates. In 2020, they made up 30%. In 2022-2023, about 32%.

Yet they represent about 5% of the Canadian population.

Nearly one in two federally sentenced women is Indigenous.

In Ipeelee, Justice LeBel had written of:

“a truly fit and proper sentence in the particular case”
Justice Louis LeBel, Supreme Court of Canada, R. v. Ipeelee, 2012

Today, Indigenous organizations, judges and lawyers continue to build courts and programs. They draw on each Nation's knowledge.

Ubuntu, for its part, reminds us that no one exists alone. So no one stands before a judge alone. They come with a family, a community, a history.

Listening to that whole story is a way of remembering that they belong to an "us" larger than the courtroom.

And you?

Can we repair the bond broken by a crime without listening to the story that came before it?

Pass this story on

Figures

32%of federal inmates were Indigenous in 2022-2023
5%of the Canadian population is Indigenous
6 to 1Supreme Court vote in Ipeelee (2012)

Sources

  1. Indigenous people in the criminal justice system: overrepresentation, background paper 2020-46-F (Library of Parliament, 2020, French version) lop.parl.ca
  2. Spirit Matters, backgrounder to the 2022-2023 annual report (Office of the Correctional Investigator, 2023) www.oci-bec.gc.ca
  3. The healing power of Gladue reports (Policy Options, 2018, French version) policyoptions.irpp.org
  4. R v Ipeelee (Wikipedia) en.wikipedia.org

Every figure on this page links to a verifiable public source.

Tags

Read also

Thread 05

Jordan first: when the child comes before the paperwork

Jordan River Anderson died in 2005 while two governments argued over who would pay for his care; his name became a simple principle: the child first.

Read
Thread 05

Seeing with Both Eyes

A Mi'kmaw Elder from Nova Scotia, Albert Marshall, invites us to look at the world with two eyes: one for Indigenous knowledges, the other for Western science.

Read
Thread 05

Forgiving without forgetting

Forgiveness erases neither the wrong nor the memory. Where it has taken root, in South Africa as in Rwanda, the truth first had to be told.

Read

The daily story

Get every story by email.

One true story a day, free and ad-free.

Or follow the RSS feed.